My Business Isn't Working — Kill It or Push Harder?
Five checks that tell you whether you have a demand problem, a delivery problem, or just a patience problem.
Most failing businesses don't fail loudly. They plateau, and the founder spends another year improving things that were never the problem: the site, the logo, the funnel, the positioning deck. Meanwhile the actual question — does anyone want this enough to pay for it repeatedly — goes unanswered because answering it is frightening.
Sunk cost makes it worse. Two years in, 'was this the right idea' feels like a verdict on you rather than on a product. It isn't. Run the checks.
Work through it in five steps
1. Do you have repeat buyers, or only first-time ones?
Anyone can sell a first one to friends and goodwill. Repeat purchase, renewal or referral is the only signal that the thing works. If nobody comes back, no amount of top-of-funnel fixes it.
2. Have you ever asked the people who said no?
Ten five-minute conversations with people who didn't buy is worth more than three months of redesign. Most founders have never done this because the answers sting.
3. Is the problem reach or resonance?
If a hundred qualified people saw it and two bought, that's a product problem. If ten saw it, you don't have data — you have a distribution problem, and that's a much better one to have.
4. What's the honest hourly rate?
Divide last quarter's profit by the hours you put in. Not to shame yourself — to see whether you're running a business or funding a job you'd never accept from an employer.
5. Set a kill line with a date
Pick the number and the date now, while calm: 'if I don't have X paying customers by 30 November, I stop.' A decision made in advance is the only defence against sunk cost made at 1am.
Signs you've already decided
- Revenue is flat but you keep changing the website.
- Your customers are mostly people who already knew you.
- You can't name three people who'd be genuinely annoyed if you shut down.
- You've rebranded more often than you've raised prices.
- You're busiest in the parts of the business nobody pays for.
Four minds, four different answers
AI parody written in the style of each public figure. Not real quotes, not endorsements, not professional advice.
Steve Jobs
"You don't have a marketing problem, you have too many things. Cut the list to the one thing that would still matter if the other nine disappeared, and make that noticeably better than the alternative."
Jordan Belfort
"Nothing is broken until you've had a hundred real conversations. Twenty calls a day for a week beats another quarter of building. If a hundred people say no in the same words, that's your answer and it took a week."
Gary Vaynerchuk
"Patience on the vision, impatience on the tactics. If nobody's talking about it, you're not making anything worth talking about — document the work publicly and see who shows up."
Simon Cowell
"You want honesty, so: it's not that the idea is terrible, it's that it's forgettable. Forgettable is worse. Change the thing people describe to their friends, or stop."
Now put your actual situation in
The framework above is generic on purpose. Your version isn't. Paste the real details — the numbers, the message, the part you haven't said out loud — and get an answer written for your case. Three questions are free, no account needed.
Ask about this